Well, I am angry, actually? It felt like this post was an invitation to discuss a genre I like and think about what it means collectively, so I'm kind of angry that when I offered my own definition of noblebright and my thought on the genre, I got a wall of text from an anthology I have not heard of in reply.

If I don't get to make observations about noblebright without being told I am wrong bc an authority has a different definition, why are we pretending we get to have an opinion about the definition of another movement? An authority should give an authoritative definition,if that's the case.