rachelmanija (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
rachelmanija) wrote2012-05-22 11:20 am
rachelmanija) wrote2012-05-22 11:20 am
Entry tags:
Everybody Sees The Ants, by A. S. King
I have a bit of a quandary. This is probably the best YA novel I've read this year to date (though I have not yet read Code Name Verity
), but it's hard to discuss what makes it good without getting into giant spoilers. I read it without even reading the cover copy, and that was probably the best way to approach it.
It starts when Lucky Linderman, age fifteen, gets a parent-teacher meeting called because he used his social studies assignment to do a survey to ask, "If you were going to commit suicide, what method would you choose?" He tells them it was a joke; actually, he was attempting to amuse and so placate his nemesis, the school bully. The survey proceeds to take on a life of its own, which continues throughout the book.
Meanwhile, every night, in surreal, often darkly funny episodes, Lucky dreams of trying to rescue his forty-years-since MIA grandfather from Vietnam. Spoiler text spoils something that, in the book, is revealed on page 36. It's a good reveal. He can take physical items from the dreams back into reality.
Very cleverly plotted, well-written, funny, well-characterized, and an interesting mix of genres. The interconnected intricacy of imagery, plot, and theme reminded me of Louis Sachar's Holes
or Rebecca Stead's When You Reach Me
.
I liked how it dealt with a ridiculous number of Very Serious Issues without reading like a problem novel about bullying/POWs/suicide/Etc. I'm not sure that the resolution of the plotline about the bully worked as well as the other storyline conclusions, but that was about my only criticism. I had a general idea of how the Vietnam storyline had to resolve, but the specifics were surprising and satisfying. Highly recommended.
Has anyone read anything else by King? She has two other novels, but I never even heard of her before. Sherwood recommended this, an Andre Norton Award finalist.
Everybody Sees the Ants
), but it's hard to discuss what makes it good without getting into giant spoilers. I read it without even reading the cover copy, and that was probably the best way to approach it. It starts when Lucky Linderman, age fifteen, gets a parent-teacher meeting called because he used his social studies assignment to do a survey to ask, "If you were going to commit suicide, what method would you choose?" He tells them it was a joke; actually, he was attempting to amuse and so placate his nemesis, the school bully. The survey proceeds to take on a life of its own, which continues throughout the book.
Meanwhile, every night, in surreal, often darkly funny episodes, Lucky dreams of trying to rescue his forty-years-since MIA grandfather from Vietnam. Spoiler text spoils something that, in the book, is revealed on page 36. It's a good reveal. He can take physical items from the dreams back into reality.
Very cleverly plotted, well-written, funny, well-characterized, and an interesting mix of genres. The interconnected intricacy of imagery, plot, and theme reminded me of Louis Sachar's Holes
or Rebecca Stead's When You Reach Me.I liked how it dealt with a ridiculous number of Very Serious Issues without reading like a problem novel about bullying/POWs/suicide/Etc. I'm not sure that the resolution of the plotline about the bully worked as well as the other storyline conclusions, but that was about my only criticism. I had a general idea of how the Vietnam storyline had to resolve, but the specifics were surprising and satisfying. Highly recommended.
Has anyone read anything else by King? She has two other novels, but I never even heard of her before. Sherwood recommended this, an Andre Norton Award finalist.
Everybody Sees the Ants
no subject
no subject
no subject
Apropos of very little, have you read Jon Skovron's MISFIT? It's probably my favorite read of the year - though very different than A.S. King. It has mixed reviews online but it hits almost every single storytelling kink that I have and I am madly in love with it.
Technically I think it came out in 2011, but I'm slow on the uptake sometimes.
(Also, Jon is awesome, which is always an added bonus.)
no subject
no subject
The reality: It tends to kick a lot of tropes in the face, is every bit as much the story of her parents as it is about Jael (the protagonist), explores a luscious amount of mythology and the evolution of religious icons.
I'd call it American Gods meets Daughter of Smoke and Bone. I'm so, so sad there won't be more of these books (I think it didn't perform well enough for Amulet to pick up sequels).
Additionally, it is told in both third person past and third person present, the latter of which is a particular soft spot for me.
no subject
no subject
no subject
I find my friends' reviews a very reliable source of recommendations these days. Thank you for making the effort to write them up.
no subject
---L.
no subject
no subject
no subject
---L.
no subject
no subject
no subject
I see what you mean about the bullying conclusion, but I think it would have been hard to do something significantly different while keeping it believable.
no subject
It's smart, comic, and sad. I can't wait to see what happens next.