Koontz tends to write books with absolutely killer hooks and intros, but is much more uneven about middles and conclusions that live up to them. I am still annoyed that The Bad Place, which has the wonderful premise of a contemporary man who travels to an unknown planet or land in his sleep, sometimes bringing back riches and sometimes terrors, proceeded to an only barely related plot about detectives and genetic engineering rather than exploring the super-cool actual premise. This book also has a killer hook, and also proceeds to go in an unusual direction with it, but one which I found much more satisfying and surprising.

Jim Ironheart gets psychic commands to go save people, but doesn’t know who they’ll be or why they’re in danger until he gets there, and he never knows why that person rather than some other, out of all the people who are in danger every day. Reporter Holly Thorne finds out about him and, fascinated, approaches him to find out what the hell is going on. The two of them are attracted, but the romance takes second place to the mystery of who’s commanding Jim and why… and why they both are having terrifying nightmares that start manifesting in reality.

This is a really gripping, creepy book. It has horror elements, but it’s not really a horror novel. It’s more of a cross-genre thriller. And that’s all I can say without huge spoilers.

There’s a point where Jim is busy romancing Holly in a way that is just a little bit too romance-conventional considering the other weird shit going on. I thought, “This is a little weird and fast and it makes it seem like there’s something off about this guy, entirely apart from the obvious bizarre stuff surrounding him. If this was real life, he’d be psychotic, a serial killer, or at best profoundly psychologically messed up. But I think it’s just Koontz doing a bad job with romance conventions.”

HA HA NO. It is totally deliberate! Exactly one paragraph later, Holly has the exact same thought as me!

Jim IS profoundly psychologically messed up! The nightmares, the commands, the manifestations, and the evil that pursues them is all him – he has tremendous psychic powers, but due to trauma repressed everything and created an entire drama for himself in which he’s the hero and is pursued by an alien evil… which is basically mental fanfic of his favorite fantasy book when he was a kid, that he has the power to make real! It’s not exactly real-world psychology, but it makes sense in context and Koontz did a great job of having the reader slowly start thinking stuff like, “This seems a little weird/cheesy/convenient” right before Holly does.

The very ending falls a little flat because the romance is still going on even though the man the reader and Holly knew throughout the book was a child’s idea of a hero, not a real person, and the post-cathartic realization Jim is going to have to create a new (real this time) personality from scratch. But it’s still a really fun, clever, surprising book.

Cold Fire
sholio: sun on winter trees (Default)

From: [personal profile] sholio

... huh! I noped out of this one about a third of the way into it because it seemed like such conventional Koontz fare and I was bored. Looks like I quit too soon, because that is a cool twist.

(At some point my husband and I read our way through a string of Koontzes with such great beginnings and terrible, disappointing endings that we started to refer to it as "Koontzing the ending", i.e. the exact opposite of sticking the landing. We still say that sometimes when a book drastically fails to live up to expectations at the very end.)

From: [identity profile] egelantier.livejournal.com

oh! oh!!! i read this book when i was a kid, and somehow ended up with a conclusion that he's a good writer. which, as further exploration later on shown, is not exactly a case.

i don't even remember anything else about the book, but the premise is totally it, i've just had this flash of OH THAT'S WHAT IT IS.

From: [identity profile] rachelmanija.livejournal.com

He's sometimes a good writer. I would say that he is extraordinarily good at some specific writing skills (hooks, page-turning/readability), often good at other skills (plotting, likable characters), but unfortunately not consistently good at any of them. Other writing skills sometimes distinctly lacking.

But what he does in this book is really clever and well-executed. Also pretty ballsy, considering how much of it plays on the reader thinking, "This seems implausible/poorly written/dumb… No wait, there is an actual reason for that!"

From: [identity profile] axolotl9.livejournal.com

I seem to recall

that, at the time it was written, it was also a "near-future" type of novel as the traumatic incident was pretty clearly a fictionalization of a recent news event (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/San_Ysidro_McDonald's_massacre).

From: [identity profile] axolotl9.livejournal.com

RE: Re: I seem to recall

I was thinking of the McDonald's massacre in 1984, but looking at the the publication date, it is closer to Luby's.

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags