In an alternate Los Angeles, there are canals instead of freeways (but the boat traffic jams anyway) and osteomancers gain the powers of ancient animals by mining the La Brea Tar Pits and eating their bones. The magic then settles into their bones, leading to a highly unfortunate situation in which you can gain the collected power of an osteomancer by eating... them.
In this fantastically realized alt-historical/urban fantasy setting, Daniel Blackland is the son of a famous osteomancer who infused him with power before getting killed and eaten by the current ruler of Los Angeles, the Hierarch. Rather than seeking revenge, Daniel laid low and became a highly skilled but basically mid-level thief, running a crew consisting of Jo (a shapeshifter), Cassandra (a safecracker/sharpshooter), and Moth (a fighter who can regenerate like Wolverine.)
But there's another man who also had a parent killed and eaten by the Hierarch. Gabriel Argent also sought survival over revenge, but took a completely different route. He works for the Hierarch as a highly skilled but basically mid-level investigator, whose true love is bureaucracy and city planning. When his sharp eye for oddities puts him on Daniel's trail, he borrows Max, a Hound - a highly trained and specialized slave, treated like a police dog only with less kindness. Gabriel sees potential in Max, a highly competent depressed nihilist who is under a death sentence for murdering his original handler. Their relationship was tied with the worldbuilding/magic system/sense of place for my favorite part of the book.
sholio has a review with way more detail on Gabriel & Max.
This book is basically a cross between The Lies of Locke Lamora minus the misogyny, a visit to the La Brea Tar Pits, and my "i love la" tag.
The LA-ness was SO GOOD. It feels 100% local and real and lived-in, not the sort of outsider's view of what's important about LA and its history that you often get. I literally knew EXACTLY where most of it was taking place, down to random warehouses. At one point Tito's Tacos makes a crucial appearance. That's that taco joint by the freeway three blocks from my old apartment! I cracked up that Daniel also thinks it overrated, which is a very unpopular opinion.
I also liked that okay, you get some world famous Hollywood figures, but you also get William Mulholland as a water wizard controlling the Department of Water & Power (both kinds of power), and the whole plot turns on things like the La Brea Tar Pits and LA not naturally having water.
The social/political aspects really worked for me. The central problem, which is the literal devouring of natural resources until the powerful are literally eating the powerless, is makes sense both as a metaphor and as a reality within the world of the book.
The magic system was fantastic. There's aspects which are underexplained (mostly non-osteomantic magic), but overall it's clever, evocative, original, and generally delightful. If you want super-strength, you get it from specific animals, so they're forever battling people imbued with the essences of short-faced bears, saber-tooth tigers, and, memorably, an entire herd of mammoth!
The parts of this book that were good were A+. However, it had some flaws that knock it down from excellent to very good. I think it needed one more editing pass. Several extremely important emotional moments occur entirely off-page, some of the characterization is very thin, and the crucial matter of the connections, history, and emotional bonds between Daniel and his crew are told in summary rather than shown, which made those feel thin too. There's also some significant pacing issues - the book needed at least one more chapter between the action climax and the last chapter, among other things.
My big issues fell into two general categories: important things occurring off-page, which affected the characterization and general emotional tenor, and pacing.
The book would have been SO MUCH BETTER if we'd gotten full chapters of flashback for each of Daniel's crew as actual scenes rather than Daniel narrating what happened in summary. A lot of anime/manga does this really well. It would have made the revelations seem cooler, and added a lot of depth to the characters, and given a certain spoilery revelation more punch.
Jo especially was thinly characterized, which was frustrating as it also isn't explained at all in this book how shapeshifting works and how it's different from osteomancy. A flashback chapter in which we see Daniel meet her would have helped a lot.
The explanation of why Moth can regenerate is interesting (more so in retrospect after a certain revelation, actually) but I was wildly curious while it was still a mystery, and then disappointed when Daniel just summarizes it. If it had been a flashback chapter and shown rather than told, it would have been much more satisfying.
In general, Daniel's crew is supposed to have incredibly tight and long-lived relationships, but their characterization felt thin and so I wasn't very invested in them for a lot of the book. Whereas I was extremely invested in Gabriel and Max, partly because they were cool, unusual characters, but also because they meet in the present day so we actually see their relationship develop rather than it being summary + wisecracks.
(Daniel wisecracks a lot and not very funnily. For a lot of the book he was my least favorite character.)
Other issues are super spoilery. There's one twist that made my jaw drop - it was startling, logical, perfectly done, and illuminated a whole lot of things that had happened before. I recommend that you read the book first, if you want to be surprised. But I know most of you won't, so I'll try to talk around it a little bit.
Content notes: Cannibalism, injustice, torture, police brutality, depictions of racism/colonialism, environmental issues. The book is generally very fun, but it doesn't whitewash social issues.
( Read more... )


In this fantastically realized alt-historical/urban fantasy setting, Daniel Blackland is the son of a famous osteomancer who infused him with power before getting killed and eaten by the current ruler of Los Angeles, the Hierarch. Rather than seeking revenge, Daniel laid low and became a highly skilled but basically mid-level thief, running a crew consisting of Jo (a shapeshifter), Cassandra (a safecracker/sharpshooter), and Moth (a fighter who can regenerate like Wolverine.)
But there's another man who also had a parent killed and eaten by the Hierarch. Gabriel Argent also sought survival over revenge, but took a completely different route. He works for the Hierarch as a highly skilled but basically mid-level investigator, whose true love is bureaucracy and city planning. When his sharp eye for oddities puts him on Daniel's trail, he borrows Max, a Hound - a highly trained and specialized slave, treated like a police dog only with less kindness. Gabriel sees potential in Max, a highly competent depressed nihilist who is under a death sentence for murdering his original handler. Their relationship was tied with the worldbuilding/magic system/sense of place for my favorite part of the book.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
This book is basically a cross between The Lies of Locke Lamora minus the misogyny, a visit to the La Brea Tar Pits, and my "i love la" tag.
The LA-ness was SO GOOD. It feels 100% local and real and lived-in, not the sort of outsider's view of what's important about LA and its history that you often get. I literally knew EXACTLY where most of it was taking place, down to random warehouses. At one point Tito's Tacos makes a crucial appearance. That's that taco joint by the freeway three blocks from my old apartment! I cracked up that Daniel also thinks it overrated, which is a very unpopular opinion.
I also liked that okay, you get some world famous Hollywood figures, but you also get William Mulholland as a water wizard controlling the Department of Water & Power (both kinds of power), and the whole plot turns on things like the La Brea Tar Pits and LA not naturally having water.
The social/political aspects really worked for me. The central problem, which is the literal devouring of natural resources until the powerful are literally eating the powerless, is makes sense both as a metaphor and as a reality within the world of the book.
The magic system was fantastic. There's aspects which are underexplained (mostly non-osteomantic magic), but overall it's clever, evocative, original, and generally delightful. If you want super-strength, you get it from specific animals, so they're forever battling people imbued with the essences of short-faced bears, saber-tooth tigers, and, memorably, an entire herd of mammoth!
The parts of this book that were good were A+. However, it had some flaws that knock it down from excellent to very good. I think it needed one more editing pass. Several extremely important emotional moments occur entirely off-page, some of the characterization is very thin, and the crucial matter of the connections, history, and emotional bonds between Daniel and his crew are told in summary rather than shown, which made those feel thin too. There's also some significant pacing issues - the book needed at least one more chapter between the action climax and the last chapter, among other things.
My big issues fell into two general categories: important things occurring off-page, which affected the characterization and general emotional tenor, and pacing.
The book would have been SO MUCH BETTER if we'd gotten full chapters of flashback for each of Daniel's crew as actual scenes rather than Daniel narrating what happened in summary. A lot of anime/manga does this really well. It would have made the revelations seem cooler, and added a lot of depth to the characters, and given a certain spoilery revelation more punch.
Jo especially was thinly characterized, which was frustrating as it also isn't explained at all in this book how shapeshifting works and how it's different from osteomancy. A flashback chapter in which we see Daniel meet her would have helped a lot.
The explanation of why Moth can regenerate is interesting (more so in retrospect after a certain revelation, actually) but I was wildly curious while it was still a mystery, and then disappointed when Daniel just summarizes it. If it had been a flashback chapter and shown rather than told, it would have been much more satisfying.
In general, Daniel's crew is supposed to have incredibly tight and long-lived relationships, but their characterization felt thin and so I wasn't very invested in them for a lot of the book. Whereas I was extremely invested in Gabriel and Max, partly because they were cool, unusual characters, but also because they meet in the present day so we actually see their relationship develop rather than it being summary + wisecracks.
(Daniel wisecracks a lot and not very funnily. For a lot of the book he was my least favorite character.)
Other issues are super spoilery. There's one twist that made my jaw drop - it was startling, logical, perfectly done, and illuminated a whole lot of things that had happened before. I recommend that you read the book first, if you want to be surprised. But I know most of you won't, so I'll try to talk around it a little bit.
Content notes: Cannibalism, injustice, torture, police brutality, depictions of racism/colonialism, environmental issues. The book is generally very fun, but it doesn't whitewash social issues.
( Read more... )