rachelmanija: (Savor)
([personal profile] rachelmanija Apr. 18th, 2007 06:25 pm)
My elbows are bothering me again, so this will be brief.

I was emailed a super-secret family recipe, so [livejournal.com profile] branna and I decided to try that. What transpired was in no way the fault of the recipe.

1. When I told Branna I had a mixer, she pictured one with paddles when what I actually had was one with beaters for whipping cream.

2. The mixing bowls were too small. Branna is probably still picking bits of dried batter off the walls.

3. Apparently "cream the butter and sugar" has a specific meaning that isn't "mix together until well-mixed."

4. The mixer was in no way capable of handling the doughy batter. In fact, just as we finally figured we were finished, it made an exploding noise as we turned it off.

5. The bottom burned.

6. The mixer proved to have died when the exploding noise happened, as we learned when we poured whipping cream into a bowl and attempted to turn it on. I'd just bought it, too. But failed to save the receipt.

7. Due to mixer failure, the dough was not sufficiently stirred, so the cake was full of chewy and inappropriately crunchy bits. It tasted really good, though, so in that sense the recipe stood up impressively under adverse conditions.

8. Tonight: snickerdoodles!

From: [identity profile] aeriedraconia.livejournal.com


1. Hand held electric mixers work just fine with cake batter. Do not use for cookie dough. Ever.

2. Hee. Use large mixing bowls.

3. Cream together means smoooooth.

4. Stiff dough will kill your electric mixer every time.

5. On the mixer or the cake? If it was the cake, Awwww. Move your oven rack up one row (in the middle of you oven). also, if you have aluminum foil down in the bottom of your oven, turn is so that the shiny side is down.

6. Go for a higher watt mixer next time and don't mix stiff dough with it.

7. Textured cake can be fun.

8. Mmmmm, snickerdoodles!
kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

From: [personal profile] kate_nepveu


1. I do all the time, and no-one's ever complained about the taste. Though it is work.

From: [identity profile] aeriedraconia.livejournal.com


It isn't a taste problem, it's a 'wrecks your hand mixer' problem. My exH destroyed my mixer using it to mix cookie dough. Capt, is doesna have enough power! :-)

From: [identity profile] telophase.livejournal.com


It may depend on the particular cookie and the particular mixer - I used my mom's for years to make chocolate chip cookies, and it worked just fine. :) It wasn't a cheapo hand mixer, though; it was a wedding present for her back in 1967, and is still working. :)

From: [identity profile] movingfinger.livejournal.com


Older mixers have metal gears and are nearly indestructible--you can grind one to a halt with stiff dough, but you probably won't kill it.

In the mid-80's Kitchenaid went to plastic gears and those mixers, supposedly of good quality, now burn out regularly on their owners!

That said, our newer Kenwood has far more oomph than Mom's old Sunbeam, though much less jet-age style.

From: [identity profile] vee-fic.livejournal.com


I think that creaming butter and sugar is the sort of thing that one has to have the experience of -- it didn't occur to me that a person might not just automatically know what that means. Creamed butter and sugar is the base for a lot of cookies, and some cakes, and it's this excellent texture where the butter is mooshy and permeated with sugar. And because it is pre-egg (if egg there is in the recipe at all), it is usually dented with small grabby fingerprints as soon as the creaming is complete.

(Except for Cuisinarting pie crusts, I have tended to eschew mixers in the kitchen. I beat my own whipped cream by hand! And wow was I sore afterwards, but triumphantly so!)

From: [identity profile] badnoodles.livejournal.com


Creaming generally takes at least two minutes for an average sized cake. I used a timer to make sure I've creamed it enough - though I'm getting better at finding the texture by feel, the two minute timer makes a good safety net.

From: [identity profile] rayechu.livejournal.com


Lol, so what exactly did you do with the butter and sugar, as creaming is pretty much just mixing it together until it is smooth?
oyceter: (i cook)

From: [personal profile] oyceter


HEEE! Aw man, I have to make you watch Good Eats some time, just because Alton Brown very nicely walks newbie cooks like me through every freaking step of the process. Also, TV visuals very helpful when it comes to things like "creaming" and "coating" and "mixer" and "soft peaks" and all that other complicated cooking terminology.

As television has explained to me, apparently the creaming of the butter and sugar is essential as it a) works air into the mixture (ergo the lighter color of the butter after proper creaming) and b) the sugar crystals poke teeny holes into something or the other which basically forms teeny seed bubbles that will eventually be cake bubbles that will determine the texture of the cake (even small bubbles vs. uneven large and small bubbles vs... who knows).

RIP, mixer.

Good luck on snickerdoodles!

From: [identity profile] tacithydra.livejournal.com


But (http://www.amazon.com/Science-Cooking-Peter-Barham/dp/3540674667/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2/104-0249598-9558348?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1176995057&sr=8-2) there (http://www.amazon.com/Kitchen-Chemistry-Ted-Lister/dp/0854043896/ref=pd_bbs_3/104-0249598-9558348?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1176995057&sr=8-3) are (http://www.amazon.com/What-Einstein-Told-His-Cook/dp/0393011836/ref=pd_sim_b_4/104-0249598-9558348?ie=UTF8&qid=1176995057&sr=8-2) so (http://www.amazon.com/Food-Cooking-Science-Lore-Kitchen/dp/0684800012/ref=pd_sim_b_5/104-0249598-9558348?ie=UTF8&qid=1176995057&sr=8-3") many (http://www.amazon.com/What-Einstein-Told-His-Cook/dp/B000OZ28MY/ref=pd_sim_b_5/104-0249598-9558348?ie=UTF8&qid=1176995057&sr=8-2)!

From: [identity profile] rushthatspeaks.livejournal.com


O dear. Well, I am glad to hear the recipe holds up.

From: [identity profile] oracne.livejournal.com


To make creaming together sugar and butter easier, it helps if you leave the butter out on the counter for a while first, so it's not so hard and brittle. Then I use a wooden spoon--having a hard, flat surface to smash the butter with helps a lot. The mixture should have a slightly fluffy texture when ready.
kate_nepveu: sleeping cat carved in brown wood (Default)

From: [personal profile] kate_nepveu


Alton Brown recommends room-temperature, which is squooshier than I expected, and is achieved by gently nuking the butter for 10-20 seconds at a time and stabbing it with an instant-read thermometer. =>

From: [identity profile] oracne.livejournal.com


[heh] I use my fingertip to see if it squooshes. Different strokes....

From: [identity profile] expansive.livejournal.com

practice makes perfect


speaking of baking, i will be making 4 cheesecakes over the course of my exam period. yaaaay, cheescake!

From: [identity profile] tacithydra.livejournal.com


That cake saga is almost as epic as the Mahabharata...

From: [identity profile] movingfinger.livejournal.com


To cream butter and sugar, start with room-temperature (~70 deg. F) butter. It should be unsalted, "sweet" butter, as fresh as possible. It should be room-temperature through and through, so in most places you should take it out of the fridge a few hours before you start. The butter is soft enough to work with when it is a spreadable, light consistency. You can push your finger into it. It won't feel cold.

In hot weather, it will warm up much faster; don't let it melt. If it's deforming and sagging it might be close to liquefying. You cannot cream liquid butter. Don't use the microwave.

Superfine sugar gives superior results, but isn't necessary.

Using a flat paddle mixer (a stand mixer) gives best results, but isn't necessary; however, the average hand mixer will not mix more than about three cups total of butter and sugar effectively.

Start beating the butter slowly and scrape it down often. Don't let it just clump in the mixers. The point is to beat air into it. You are making an emulsion. When the butter is light (it will appear lighter in color as well as being lighter in texture), add sugar a little at a time and speed up the mixer. Sifting it in in a continuous stream is good, stopping and sprinkling it on top works too. Don't dump it all in at once; you want it consistent in both distribution and degree of mixing. The sugar is being dissolved into the fat with air beaten in at the same time.

Properly creamed butter and suger has a texture much like extremely stiff whipped cream; it is airy, light in color, and the granularity of the sugar should not dominate.

Eggs are usually mixed in after the butter and sugar cream together. As more ingredients are added---especially at the flour stage---don't mix too much, you don't want to toughen the batter (the flour can develop gluten if overbeaten) or overbeat the eggs (and flatten them again). A key step a lot of people skip is to halt mixing and scrape the beaters and bowl, keeping the batter from stratifying.

I killed a food processor once! I've never done in a mixer though.

Mixers turn up regularly in thrift stores and yard sales.

Snickerdoodles are the best. Don't skimp on the cinnamon.

From: [identity profile] aberwyn.livejournal.com


Don't try to dump in all the sugar at once, either. I've always creamed butter and sugar together by hand using a flexible spatula. Mixers are often more trouble than they're worth, in my old-fashioned opinion.

If you get the "balloon" version of a french whip, you can whip cream or egg whites faster and better than with a mixer, just btw.

From: [identity profile] mkellis.livejournal.com


To be fair to [livejournal.com profile] rachelmanija, the person in the house who is the original owner of most of the cooking equipment, knows where the large mixing bowls are, and had a pretty good idea of what 'creaming butter and sugar' is was forted up in the back playing World of Warcraft and trying to ignore the sounds from the kitchen as much as possible.

And we now have a really good excuse to buy a stand mixer. Bait for people to come over and cook cakes.
naomikritzer: (Default)

From: [personal profile] naomikritzer


Note regarding the recipes I left: I own only a hand mixer.
.

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags